| December 5, 1958 | vs New Mexico State | W 58-52 |
| December 11, 1958 | vs Iona Gaels | W 69-52 |
| December 13, 1958 | vs Detroit Mercy | W 80-58 |
| December 19, 1958 | vs Seattle | W 80-68 |
| December 22, 1958 | vs Marquette Golden Eagles | L 71-86 |
| December 26, 1958 | vs Oregon Ducks | W 68-57 |
| December 27, 1958 | vs Oklahoma City | L 54-81 |
| December 28, 1958 | vs Bowling Green State | L 71-92 |
| January 3, 1959 | vs Louisville Cardinals | W 98-66 |
| January 6, 1959 | vs Miami (OH) | W 85-79 |
| January 10, 1959 | vs Louisville Cardinals | L 66-70 |
| January 14, 1959 | vs Dayton Flyers | L 56-60 |
| January 24, 1959 | vs Cincinnati Bearcats | L 66-92 |
| January 28, 1959 | vs Georgetown Hoyas | W 70-62 |
| January 31, 1959 | vs Notre Dame Fighting Irish | W 73-71 |
| February 2, 1959 | vs Saint Francis (PA) | L 56-59 |
| February 9, 1959 | vs Seattle | L 69-88 |
| February 11, 1959 | vs Montana State | L 81-93 |
| February 16, 1959 | vs Western Kentucky | L 67-94 |
| February 21, 1959 | vs Marquette Golden Eagles | L 70-79 |
| February 23, 1959 | vs Western Kentucky | L 73-82 |
| February 28, 1959 | vs La Salle | L 80-99 |
| March 3, 1959 | vs Miami (OH) | W 82-78 |
| March 8, 1959 | vs Dayton Flyers (14) | W 71-69 |
